Education – Module 5 Sociology and Education
Definitions
Education – process of learning over a lifetime
Schooling – institutionalized learning
Transmission – reproduction of social structures
Transformation – production of culture by activities and desires of individuals
Socialization – the process by which individuals learn the culture of their society
Norms – cultures guidelines that direct conduct in particular situations; define appropriate and acceptable behavior ins specific situations.
Values – a belief that something is good and desirable; norms are the reflections of values. Shared norms and values are essential to the operation of human society.
Status – culturally defined: ascribed status’ or achieved status.
Roles – norms defining the conduct of persons in a given status. Social roles organize and regulate behavior.
Social system – a set of interrelated elements that can be thought of as a whole. A huge variety of elements and forms of knowledge are contained in culture.back to top
Social Transmission Theories
Functionalism – all societies possess basic functions which they must carry out to survive.
- reproduce themselves
- recruit new members
- provide goods & services
- allocate power
- transmission of function
back to top
Critique: rejects conflict and change as viable social processes
Structural Functionalism – certain structures carry out various specific functions that must remain in equilibrium. Any social structure must have a function.
- educational structures function to transmit attitudes, values, skills and norms from one generation to another
-
intellectual purposes: acquisition of cognitive skill, substantive knowledge and inquiry skills
- political purposes: educate to participate in political order, promote patriotism, assimilation of immigrants, ensure order, public civility and conformity to law.
- economic purposes: prepare for entry into the workforce, maintenance of class structure
- social purposes: promote social and moral responsibility, solution of social problems, supplement efforts of other institutions.
back to top
Conflict Theory – Examine sources and consequences of conflict, organization and mobilization of groups in sources of inequalities. Organization of society determined by patterns of ownership of property.
Reproduction Theory – Schools reproduce the ideology of dominant social groups and hierarchy of class structure.
- via formal language and behavior
- by magnifying class differences
- power groups work to maintain the status quo
purposes of schooling: promote inequality and perpetuate class distinctions.
Economic reproduction: schools fail to reduce poverty and disadvantage to economic structure of capitalism.
Correspondence – economic organization mirrored in institutions
Hidden curriculum – implicit messages re appropriate behavior
Cultural reproduction – class based differences are expressed in the political nature of the curriculum content
Hegemonic State Reproduction
(A hegemony is a social consensus created by dominant groups who control socializing institutions. These dominant groups prevent alternate views from gaining audience or establishing legitimacy.)
Production of knowledge, regulation of education
Critique: disregards the power of individual human agency.back to top
Interpretive Theories
Focus on social construction of meaning in social interactions. (Reminds me of Vygotsky) Reality depends upon the situation and the people in the situation.
Phenomenology: social meaning of knowledge and significance of possessing certain knowledge.
Symbolic Interaction: link the construction of meaning with the roles that individuals and social structures play in constructing meaning.
Ethnomethodology: rules by which people order their social interaction and the way these rules are communicated.
Views schools as places where meaning is constructed through social interaction
Contribution of Interpretive Approaches:
- discovered that students of different classes received different training.
back to top
Social Transformation Theories
Critical Theory – uncovers and debunks hidden assumptions that govern society.
- despite influences of oppression there is hope because of involvement of human agency.
- Concern over social and economic inequality
As individuals learn to identify the contradictions that affect their lives they become aware of oppressive influences. They can begin to transform their lives due to growth of awareness.
They question:
What are the sources of inequality and oppression in society?
How can individuals achieve autonomy in face of societal oppression?
How do individuals experience life in social organizations?
How are language and communication patterns used to oppress?
How do people construct positive and negative identities?
- Human Agency and the Production of Culture
Classrooms are sites of cultural production where people interact to construct meaning.
Influence on pedagogy: teachers must be active, questioning learners
Purposes of schooling: critical theorists emphasize the power of individuals to structure their own destiny
An educated citizenry facilitates the preservation of a democratic and egalitarian society.
Critical theorist believe that the present function of schooling is to maintain the power of the dominant group through curriculum, methods of instruction, texts etc.back to top
What do we want to know about?
Social life and its consequences: we need to understand the variety of consequences resulting from this organization.
Social change: understand forces influencing change and the status quo.
Social systems exist only through what people experience and do in relation to one another.back to top
John Dewey
Education is an important process of development and growth. An educated person has the power to go on and get more education.
Past education failed to take into account the diversity of capacities and needs of people. It also failed to account for the fact that initiative in growth comes from the needs and powers of the pupils.
Every mind, even the youngest, is naturally or inherently seeking for those modes of active operation that are within the limits of its capacities.
A worker cannot get far if he lets the properties of his materials dictate what he does. He must, instead, bring to his consideration an ideal of possibilities not realized. This comes from seeing them imaginatively and reflectively.(A bad workman blames his tools).
Respect for individuality is primarily intellectual. It signifies the studying of the individual to see what is there to work with.
Knowledge is a possession held in trust for the furthering of the well-being of all.
An environment in which some are practically enslaved, degraded and limited will always react to create conditions that prevent the full development even of those who fancy they enjoy complete freedom for unhindered growth. (If a person is in the gutter, someone must be there too to hold him in).
back to top
Curriculum
Formal curriculum – institutional and instructional activities that provide the total overt school experience.
Hidden curriculum – subliminal messages sent to the students underlying material content and teacher conduct.back to top
Education Reform
Reforms have overlooked the complex inter-relationships between education and other institutions.
Proposals have been based on the erroneous assumption that social and economic change can result from education reform alone.back to top
Sir Arthur Lewis – Education was not invented in order to enable men to produce more goods and services. The purpose of education is to enable men to better understand the world in which they live so that they may more fully express their potential capacities whether spiritual, intellectual or material.back to top
Strategies for reforming schools
Alternative schools: schools that provide alternatives to learning average public schools. Their characteristics are enrollment of students who have not succeeded in traditional schools and students who want a different kind of education.
Magnet schools: Attracts students on voluntary basis by adapted curricular design meant to appeal to a special field or a distinctive approach.
Systematic reform:
- innovations should be adaptive; can identify and solve day to day implementation problems
- focus for change at level of individual facility (autonomy)
- implementation requires change in a variety of institutional arrangements (principal is the key)
- teachers should have a voice
- systematically examine the implications and plan to overcome obstacles.
Rational reform: reform is ideally a technical exercise carried out by experts utilizing the most advanced techniques an applying state-of-the-art knowledge.
Political reform: is the periodic renegotiation of the values guiding policy and practice; shifts in relative power of competing groups affects what changes.
Comparative reform: adjustment and changes made in response to internal and external comparisons, related to desired goals and objectives in society.
Radical reform: replacing obsolete and decadent traditions with new dynamic forms
Factors affecting reform:
- innovations that rely too heavily on technology
- success directly linked to administrative support
- innovation in curriculum and instruction is easier than innovation in organization and administration
- directives seldom effective means of implementation
Factors affecting Effective Schools
- stress on the commitment and capacity at individual school level
- strong and effective leadership
- atmosphere of the school
- high expectations for achievement
- small group and individualized instruction
- exchange of ideas among staff
- clear focus on objectives and priorities
back to top
Education – Module Adolescence
Definitions
Adolescence – refers to the age between puberty and adulthood. Adolescence begins when specific physiological criterion of sexual maturity but has no specific end time. The period of physical and psychological development from the onset of puberty to maturity.
(My definition, consolidated from several other definitions: adolescence is the phase, beginning with puberty, where a young person contends with social-psychological forces, and biological imperatives in an effort to attain identity of self and identity of society and a sense of reproductive security).
Puberty – refers to the earliest age at which a person is capable of procreating offspring. Developmental stage at which a person becomes capable of reproduction.
Pubescence – attainment or onset of puberty
Maturity – the state or quality of being mature.
Adulthood – the state of being mature or of legal age.
Metacognition – knowledge people have about their own thinking process
Disequilibrium – an imbalance created by unexpected or previously not previously experienced events or information.back to top
Characteristics of Adolescents
Physical Development: important because it affects the adolescents’ self-perceptions and how they deal with the development of their identity.
Cognitive Development – (Piaget) A stage of transition from the use of concrete operations to the application of formal operation in reasoning. Concrete operational thinkers can think logically. Their new abilities include the reversibility of operations. Though their thinking is de-centered, but students have not developed abstract thinking. Formal operational thinkers can use abstract and purely symbolic thinking. Problem solving skills include systematic experimentation. (Vygotsky) Cognitive development is strongly linked to input from others. Children internalize signs to be able to think and solve problems without the help of others (self-regulation). Zone of proximal development: the level of development immediately above the present level.
Class notes on Piaget: Piaget focused on error making; he was trying to understand how errors came about. Constructivism is at the core of Piaget’s theory.
Vygotsky criticized Piaget for not considering the socio-cultural aspect of development at all. Vygotsky felt that cognitive development was not stage-like and that one could not have cognitive development without social interaction. Vygotsky’s focus was that what learners and adults/peers do together promote learning and development. Development takes place in a social context. They acquire knowledge about their culture and history from encounters with adults/peers/media. Cultural knowledge includes: shared beliefs/ways of viewing the world/patterns of interacting with others & language. Cognitive development is a child’s increasing mastery over the culturally determined developmental tasks imposed by social agents. A child will not attain mastery as the sole investigator of its environment; mastery stems from social interaction.
- A child develops social knowledge first; beliefs/attitudes/ thinking and reasoning that are important to the community.
- cultural and historical knowledge second; presented in institutions; beginning to think independently and internalize their culture; take on more responsibility for acquiring knowledge.
Information processing perspective: sees changes in cognitive abilities as gradual transformations in the capacity to take in, use and store information.
Socio-emotional Development – adolescents seek to be more grown up and want their parents to treat them differently.
Identity – a keen awareness and self-consciousness regarding newly forming place in society due to increased intellectual capacities. Development of the ability to see various aspects of the self simultaneously viewing them as abstractions.
Identity Development – one of the first signs of early adolescence is reflectivity: the tendency to analyze oneself and ones own thoughts.
Adolescent’s Identity – keen awareness and self-consciousness regarding newly forming place in society due to increased intellectual capacities and physical changes of puberty. (Development of the ability to see various aspects of the self simultaneously viewing traits as abstractions).
Self esteem – knowing self vs. liking self
Information Processing Perspectives
- sees changes in cognitive abilities as gradual transformations in the capacity to take in, use and store information.
Selman Perspective Taking
Mutual role taking (10 – 12) Children can consider their view point and the view point of someone else simultaneously. (others may feel differently even if they know what I know and the individual can understand why they feel that way).
Social and conventional role taking (12+) Awareness of how most people would view and event. (can consider several points of view and transcend to assume the viewpoint of society).
Marcia’s Four Identity Statuses
Foreclosure – prematurely established identity on the basis of parent’s choices rather than their own. (identity through others)
Identity diffusion – no occupational or ideological commitment (unresolved identity crisis) (try many decide upon none)
Moratorium – begin to experiment with occupational and ideological choices, but no definite commitments.(explore various roles; extended crisis)
Identity achievement – identity consolidation- conscious, clear-cut decisions about occupation and ideology. (identity through crisis)
Erikson’s Stages of personal and social development
Stage V 12-18 years Identity vs. Role Confusion
Significant relationships: peers and models of leadership
Psychosocial emphasis: to be oneself and to share being oneself
(Class Notes:
- social-personality development is a life-long process;
- institutions in society exist to allow adolescents to develop via exploration;
- early experiences in culture establish who you become as an adult.
- Teens seek to determine what is unique and distinctive about their selves.
- They may adopt socially unacceptable roles; have difficulty forming and maintaining relationships;
- fail to organize around a core identity
- the cognitive sophistication that allows adolescents to differentiate various aspects of the self also leads them to evaluate those aspects in different ways
- clarify their identity through comparison with others
- the development of the person is inextricably linked to the social/cultural context the person is developing in
- peers influence is critical; they set the parameters
- goal is to find our identity, the extent to which this is accomplished depends on all prior stages.
- Personal identity through culture; relationships depend upon healthy identity development)
Piaget’s Stages of Moral Development
Autonomous Morality
– based on relations of cooperation and mutual recognition
- rational moral attitudes: rules are products of mutual agreement, open to renegotiation
- badness is relative to intentions, fairness as equal treatment
- punishment affected by human intention
Kohlberg’s Stages of Moral Reasoning
Adolescents are between the conventional level and the post conventional level
Stage 3 (conventional)– Good Boy, Good Girl: good behavior is what helps and is approved by others.
Stage 4 – (most adults) (conventional) Law and Order: right is doing one’s duty, showing respect for authority, maintaining social order for its own sake.
Stage 5 – (post-conventional) right is defined by general individual rights and societal standards. Laws can be changed for their own sake.
Jerome Bruner
Learning is a process of forming categories. Categories related from general to specific are coding systems. Concept maps enable students to discover the structure of a field of study. Teaching should enable students to discover the structure for themselves.
- Enactive Mode – child manipulates objects and in the process develops the ability to conceptualize.
- Iconic Mode – child uses picture or images and not objects to represent reality
- Symbolic Mode – child becomes capable of manipulating symbols and translating experience into reality.
Concrete models Pictorial models
Pictorial symbols symbols real world problems
Concrete models symbols
Real world models pictorial models symbols back to top
Educational Implications of Theories for Adolescents
Implications of Piaget’s Theory
- developmentally appropriate education
- teachers must appreciate children’s methods of arriving at conclusions
- crucial role of children’s self-initiated, active involvement in learning
- de-emphasize making children adult-like in their thinking
- recognition, acceptance and adaptation to individual differences back to top
Implications of Vygotsky’s Theory
- mixed group cooperative learning; effective means of promoting growth in zone of proximal development
- scaffolding; students gradually taking more responsibility for their own learning
- plan activities that children can learn with the help of others. back to top
Implications of Erickson’s Theory
Stage IV – Industry vs. Inferiority: success brings feelings of industry; good feelings about self and one’s abilities. Give students opportunity to experience success.
- Stage V – Identity vs. Role Confusion: Students experiment with new sexual, occupational and educational roles. Activities should build up students’ self-identity as successful learners. back to top
Implications of Moral Development (Kohlberg & Piaget)
- Global/district wide: activities that emphasize individual as citizen & member of a social institution. Provide students with a framework of expected behavior, students create and maintain guidelines (Classroom Mgt. Too)
- local level/classroom instruction: students allowed to test hypothetical situations & potential consequences. Creation of cognitive conflict to stimulate social perspective taking.
- individual level/conflict management: children explore boundaries between their own legitimate personal needs and goals and legitimate needs and goals of others. Collaborative classrooms to develop autonomous and socially competent individuals. back to top
Implications of Bruner’s Theories
- organization of subject matter according to underlying concepts and principles
- discovery learning helps children acquire the knowledge of the structure of the subject matter
- anything can be taught to a child; choose appropriate mode and simplify the form
- trial and error facilitates discovery
- teacher aids learning by fostering intrinsic motivation & feedback
- vary aids to facilitate concept formation
- discovery aids to increase transferability and retention
- spiral curriculum allows redevelopment of concepts & helps children acquire coding systems. back to top
Problems in Adolescence
Egocentrism is a contributing factor:
- highly critical of authority figures, unwilling to accept criticism and quick to find fault with others.
- Imaginary audience, perception that they are focus of everyone else’s attention
- Personal fables : view that what happened to them is unique, exceptional and shared by no-one else.
Achievement – their perspective of self affects this: for example, Asian students perceive their major task during adolescence is to achieve high levels of academic success.
Drugs – perceived pleasure, thrill factor, peer pressure, escape (prevent confrontation of problems)
Alcohol – adult thing to do, release of inhibitions, uncontrolled habit (alcoholism)
Tobacco – to be cool or “in”, biological and psychological dependence
STDs – prone to risky behavior due to feelings of invulnerability
Depression – biological factors, loss of loved one, depressed parent, unpopular, rejections, stress
Suicide – signs: direct/indirect references; decline in grades; making unusual final arrangements; writing a will; change in eating patterns; general depression; dramatic behavior change; pre-occupation with death.
Juvenile Delinquency: both undersocialized and socialized delinquency
Dating and sexual behavior: learning how to establish intimacy with others; masterb. Useful means of learning about own sexuality; intercourse (double standard: ok for boys not for girls)
Teen pregnancy – no father help, abandonment of education, relegated to low paying jobs. back to top
Adolescents in relationships: family and friends
Parents
- Quest for autonomy: parents and children end up in a more symmetrical or egalitarian relationship.
- Myth of generation gap: agreement in a variety of domains; agree in value they place on their relationships. Gap exists more in matters of personal taste.
- New intellectual sophistication leads to teens thinking over parents’ rules in more complex ways.
- Majority of teens maintain stable relations w/ parents
Peers
- most important time for peers
- compare and evaluate opinions
- reference group for teen norms
- cliques: members with frequent social interactions
- popularity and rejection: popular/controversial/rejected/neglected
- peer pressure: matters of personal taste; nonsocial matters of career or problem solving teens turn to experienced adults.
Dating and Sexual Behavior
- Functions of dating: learning how to establish intimacy with others
- Masturbation: useful means of learning about own sexuality
- Intercourse: males are more likely to engage in than females (double standard)
back to top
Planning and Instruction
PLANNING
Definitions
Unit plan – a planned sequence of learning activities or lessons covering a period of several weeks and centered on some major concept, theme or topic.
Lesson plan – a planned sequence of learning activities covering a concept for a period of teaching.
Backward planning – plan a course, plan a large unit, plan lessons
Teaching Strategies – methods of teaching appropriate to the learning situation.
Instructional Objectives (also known as Behavioral objectives) – a statement of the concepts, attitudes or skills that students are expected to have accomplished by the end of some period of instruction; these specify the amount of behavior that can be expected from the instruction under the specified conditions.
General objectives – broad aims of instruction with an emphasis on the means (method) of instruction.
Specific objectives – give instruction clearer direction in terms of measurable learning outcomes.
Lesson plan - a written procedure that states learning objectives, activities, information and experiences the teacher will provide, the time allotted, materials needed and instructional method to be used.
Taxonomy of objectives – a guide that contains a range of types of learning outcomes to consider when planning lessons. back to top
Introduction
- Planning is the process by which teachers decide how next to select and organize a learning experience to maximize both teacher and student achievement and satisfaction.
- Planning requires one to review content to gain confidence about teaching
- Planning requires one to think through instruction; select optimal instructional method
- Planning organizes the whole teaching act so that instruction and assessment can be effectively linked
- Planning facilitates one’s ability to meet the needs of all types of learners and all levels of learning
- Planning permits one to select the best materials possible for a lesson
- Planning permits one to manage time better
- Planning allows one to consider participation structures
- Planning allows one to orient students to the lesson, plan to generate an attitude of readiness
- Planning allows one to consider the pre-requisites students need for a learning task
- Planning allows one to execute meaningful activities and learning experiences
- Planning helps provide structure to learning back to top
Unit Plans
Unit plans establish objectives for a unit, estimate the number of periods for each objective and allows for preparation of a unit assessment.
Components of a Unit Plan
Title: topic or theme under study
- Introduction
- Rationale why the unit is important
- Should answer the “why do I have to do this?” question
- Scope and sequence of unit
- Main ideas and order in which they are addressed
- Shows how the main ideas build on each other and how the unit flows
- Time frame: when unit will begin and end
- General Objectives
- States the non-specific attitudes, knowledge or skill the students will acquire through this unit
- Body
- Content outline
- Main points
- Supporting points
- Activities
- What can be done with a class or individuals to accomplish the unit objectives
- Sequence of instruction
- List of resources expected to be useful
- Evaluation
- How will learners be evaluated in terms of achievement and satisfaction
- To what extent do they know what they are expected to know
- To what extent can they do what they are expected to do
- Bibliography
- Presents the resources and references related to the unit
- References useful to the students back to top
Lesson Plans - Formats
- Descriptive Heading – subject, topic, duration of lesson
- Demographics of the class – age range, number in class, gender
- Pre-requisites -
- Objectives – general aim or goal with specific behavioral objectives (see section on behavioral objectives below)
- Materials – all materials one needs to execute the lesson
- Content – section describing the content you will be covering, description of ideas, information relative to objectives, information one wants the students to learn, higher order content, lower order content
- Introduction – the catch, interest grabber, the mental set (attention getting phase)
- Developmental steps – a step by step description of activities that students will undertake to achieve your objectives; logically organized, clear language, explanations, demonstrations or models, variety of activities to maintain attention, content coverage and pacing.
- Conclusion – consolidate the lesson, summarize and highlight important aspects
- Evaluation – plan for how you will determine if the objectives were achieved. back to top
Lesson Objectives
Planning lesson objectives
- An objective is a statement of skills or concepts students should master after a given period of instruction
- Objectives must be adapted to the subject matter being taught
- Use words that are specific enough to be meaningful
back to top
Behavioral objectives
- Conditions under which learning will be assessed
- Performance expected of the student Mager (1975)
- Criterion for success
back to top
Task Analysis (Gagne 1977)
- Break down a task into subskills
- Identify pre-requisite skills
- Identify component skills
- Plan how to assemble components into a final skill
back to top
Critiques of specific objectives
- teachers will only emphasize learning outcomes that are easily observed and measured
- spontaneity of learning may be lost
- the ability to write an objective is not the same as the ability to effectively implement them
back to top
Taxonomies (Domain and Level)
If objectives are written only at the knowledge level, students will be unmotivated, have a limited ability to express themselves, unable to develop life skills and be unable to gain an understanding of the underlying structure and meaning of what they are studying. back to top
Cognitive Domain (Bloom’s Taxonomy)
- KNOWLEDGE
- Emphasis on remembering information
- Define, state, name, recall, identify
- COMPREHENSION
- Emphasis on understanding and organizing previously learned information
- Relate, describe, rephrase, compare, summarize, interpret, translate, explain
- E.g. to interpret information on a graph
- APPLICATION
- Emphasis on using information in pertinent situations
- Give example, apply solve, demonstrate, compute, prepare, classify, use
- Use knowledge or principles to solve practical problems
- ANALYSIS
- Emphasis on thinking critically about information by studying its parts
- Give reasons, analyze, conclude, infer, generalize, identify causes and motives, support or provide evidence.
- Having students relate to the underlying structure
- SYNTHESIS
- Emphasis on original thinking about information by putting its parts into a new whole
- Develop, predict, create, synthesize, compose, devise, build, solve, write, produce, speculate, hypothesize
- EVALUATION
- Emphasis on making judgments about information based on identified standards
- Decide, evaluate, appraise, judge, select, take a position for or against back to top
Affective Domain (Krathwohl)
The degree of internalization is the unifying hierarchical factor underlying the affective taxonomy.
- RECEIVING
- Emphasis on becoming aware of some communication or phenomenon from the environment
- Attend, listen
- RESPONDING
- Emphasis on reacting to a communication or phenomenon
- Read, write, tell, practice
- VALUING
- Emphasis on attaching worth to something from the environment
- Appreciate, follow, form, justify, choose, demonstrate, show, value
- ORGANIZATION
- Emphasis is on conceptualization of a value and organization of a value system
- CHARACTER
- Emphasis is on development from the organized value system to a generalized set of values; characterization
back to top
Psychomotor Domain
GENERIC MOVEMENT
- Emphasis on becoming aware of and displaying basic movement
ORDINATE MOVEMENT
- emphasis on organizing perceptual motor abilities to accomplish tasks
CREATIVE MOVEMENT
- creating movement in personal, unique ways
INSTRUCTIONAL TECHNIQUES
Definitions
Discussion – an educative, reflective and structured group conversation back to top
DISCUSSION METHOD
Subjective and Controversial Topics
- issues that lend themselves to multiple/diverse explanations
- found to increase knowledge about issues and encourage a deeper understanding of various sides of an issue
Difficult and Novel concepts
- useful for topics that do no have a single right answer but which involve difficult concepts that force students to see something in a different way
Affective Objectives
- objectives that are concerned with attitudes and values
- group discussion involving public commitment is a more effective way of changing attitudes and behaviors
Whole class discussions
- entire class discusses an issue with teacher as moderator
- teacher plays less dominant role than in other instructional techniques
- guides discussion
- helps avoid dead ends
- ideas should be drawn from students
- inquiry oriented discussion
- exploring points of view
- get students to use specifics to defend their position
- be sure students have adequate knowledge before beginning the discussion
Small group discussions
- a discussion among 4-6 students in a group working independently of a teacher
- should follow the presentation of information
- have a teacher-appointed leader whose role it is to ensure the group stays on topic and all members participate
- prepare the students to work in groups
- present a well organized task
Theoretical Base
- discussions characterized by student-to-student interactions & educational objectives related to complex thinking processes and attitude change
- encourage students to assume discussion leadership responsibility
- concern for rationality, fairness and respect for other people’s feelings and opinions
- effective for five types of learning outcomes
- subject matter mastery
- problem solving
- moral development
- attitude change and development
- communication skills
Logical Conditions Needed
- people must talk, listen and respond to one another
- must offer more than one point of view
- intention must be to enhance knowledge, understanding or judgment on a subject
Discussion – Method Phases
- Phase I: Identification of a problem, issue or topic
- Entry
- Use a springboard
- Identify a problem, issue or topic
- State objectives and rationale
- Phase II: Clarification
- Establish procedures
- Respect the opinions of others
- No talking when others are talking
- define terms and concepts related to the problem, issue or topic relative to complexity
- Phase III: Investigation (main body of discussion)
- Ask appropriate level of questions to achieve desired levels of student thinking
- Use questioning and alternative non-questioning techniques to maintain discussion and stimulate student involvement and thinking
- Encourage initiative and leadership
- Request students support the opinions they offer
- Ensure sufficient coverage
- Phase IV: Closure, Summary, Integration, Application
- Summarize in form of consensus, solutions, insights, issues, problem investigated
- Integrate lessons with goals and previously learned information
- Apply discussion outcomes to other situations
- Small groups would present their findings
back to top
QUESTIONING
Module Notes:
- Questions are used to find out something people do not already know.
- Questions are the stock in trade of teachers
- Teachers use questions to give directions, correct misbehavior, manage classroom activity, create learning situations and evaluate learning.
- In practice questions have been used less to stimulate thinking and more for factual recall and information.
- Plan for: asking good questions, how to obtain answers and how to react to responses
Slavin Notes:
- Purposes of questioning
- Prompt students to the next mental step
- Think further about previously learned material
- Start a discussion
- Learning probes: quality of response tells teacher how well students are learning the material presented in the lesson
- Enhance instructional effectiveness
- Factual questions help with factual skills
- Conceptual questions encourage students to think about concepts thereby enhancing conceptual skills
- Students gain from generating their own questions based on existing background knowledge
- Wait time
- Giving up too rapidly shows students you expect little of them
- Waiting 3-5 seconds has been shown to be best
- 6 seconds may be too long
- follow up with students who don’t respond
- Calling order
- Volunteers – allows some to avoid participating
- Math problem – all students should have the opportunity to complete it before calling on anyone
- Pose to class as a whole, then choose a student at random
- Choral response is ok when there is only one possible correct answer
Airasian Notes:
- purposes of questioning
- promote attention: engage students actively in the learning process
- promote deeper processing: verbalizing thoughts and ideas promotes thinking and reasoning
- promote learning from peers
- provide pace and control in a lesson
- brief responses: keeps students engaged and require continuous attention
- general, open-ended questions: slows pace, allows time for reflection and framing of responses.
- provide diagnostic information
- supplement informal observations in the least disruptive way
- in cooperative learning – assess the success of the group
- types of questions
- convergent questions – a single correct answer
- divergent questions – have many appropriate answers
- Christensen’s Typology of Questions
- Open-ended: questions with no definite answer that require formulation of a response
- Diagnostic: questions that require students to analyze a problem
- Information: questions that require factual information, data
- Challenge: questions about supporting evidence for a position
- Action: what could be done to solve the problem
- Sequence: questions about the order in which to do things, steps to take
- Prediction: what will happen next
- Hypothetical: what will happen in this different situation
- Extension: what are the implications of your action or steps
- Generalization: questions which require one to summarize general concepts
- Implications for instruction
- Questions should match the level of the learning objectives set
- Questions students answer should require more
- Explaining in their own words
- Applying knowledge in unfamiliar situations
- Synthesis of information into general statements
- less emphasis on lower level questions
- higher level questions require teachers to have a greater mastery of a subject area than lower level questions.
- Questioning Strategies
- Ask questions related to the objectives of instruction: consistency among objectives, instruction and questioning
- Avoid global, overly general questions
- Involve the entire class in the questioning process
- Be aware of patterns in the way questions are distributed among students
- Allow sufficient wait time
- State questions clearly and directly to avoid confusion
- Probe pupil responses with follow up questions
- Remember that instructional questioning is a social process; a public setting
- Allow private questioning time for pupils who are shy and difficult to engage in questioning
- Good questioning involves good listening and responding
- Adapt questions to language and ability level of the class
back to top
PROBLEM SOLVING/INQUIRY
Theoretical basis: learners should develop intellectual tact and sensitivity to solve problems by inquiring constantly in the classroom. (Dewey 1933).
Problem solving strategies can be taught
IDEAL problem solving strategy
Identify problems and opportunities
Define goals and represent the problem
Explore possible strategies
Anticipate outcomes (form hypotheses and act)
Look back and learn (present findings)
Means-End analysis
- Identify
- The goal to be attained
- The current situation
- What needs to be done
Polya’s problem solving strategy (mathematician)
Polya’s four steps to problem solving.
- Understand the problem
- Devise a plan
- Carry out the plan
- Look back
six specific activities that may be used at step two (Devise a plan)
- Draw a diagram or a picture.
- Use a variable to represent the unknown quantity and write and equation.
- Examine the problem to look for a pattern.
- Make a table of information.
- Solve a simpler problem as a model.
- Recall a known relationship relevant to the problem.
Obstacles to problem solving
Functional fixedness: an inability to see new uses for familiar objects
Teaching creative problem solving
- Incubation: reflect on a problem and think it through
- Suspension of judgment: consider all possibilities (brainstorming); avoid focusing on one solution too early
- Appropriate climate: environment conducive to creative thinking
- Analysis: analyze and juxtapose major characteristics of specific elements
- Thinking skills: unusual ideals, many ideas, planning, mapping possibilities, assemble facts
Types of Inquiry/Problem Solving
Guided Inquiry –
Problem posed by teacher
Teacher breaks the problem into simpler questions to be answered
Teacher may even give advice
Free Inquiry –
Students formulate the problem to be solved
Devise methods and techniques to solve the problem
Carry out the investigation
Come to a conclusion
Suited to intellectually gifted students
Modified Free Inquiry
Teacher provides the problem
Teacher acts as a resource person
Teacher uses questioning techniques to provide hints
_________________________________________________________________________
- Advantages
- Generates enthusiasm and interest in the students
- Since students find out things for themselves they tend to remember them better
- Enhances critical thinking skills and skills needed for scientific investigation
- Disadvantages
- Time consuming
- Not suited to all situations
- More suitable for intuitive and creative students
back to top
DISCOVERY (Bruner 1966)
General Notes on Discovery
A Constructivist approach to teaching in which students are encouraged to discover principles for themselves.
It is a flexible and exploratory approach
Teachers should:
Encourage informed guessing
Use a variety of materials
Let students satisfy their curiosity
Use plenty of examples that contrast the subject matter to related topics
Self-regulated learning (Bandura 1991) – students have knowledge of effective learning strategies and how and when to use them.
Scaffolding (Bruner 1976) – provide students with initial structure and gradually turn over responsibility to them.
Nature of Approach
Discovery occurs when an individual is involved mainly in using his mental processes to mediate (discover) some concept or principle; the mental assimilation by which the individual grasps a concept or principle from physical and mental activity.
Discovery learning leads first to an understanding of concepts, then generalizations, then principles and even laws related to the concepts.
Discovery implies induction: learners precede from specific examples to general principles.
What are concepts?
Concepts are the collective sum of precepts (related perceptions that can be categorized) is a concept. (for example, the concept of food is a collective concept of all things (precepts) that we can safely eat).
There are a wide variety of concepts: concrete, abstract, processes, relations in time or space.
Concepts are modified and revised to take into account new information a person assimilates.
Generalizations or principles are statements based on observations of the environment which describe the normal course of events.
Teaching concepts using the discovery method: implications for teaching
- describe the performance expected of the student after he has learned the concept
- reduce the number of simpler concepts (attributes) needed for a thorough understanding of a complex concept.
- Provide students with useful verbal mediators (give the concept a name, Wittrock 1974)
- Provide positive and negative examples of the concept
- Use enough positive examples to represent the range of the concept being taught (Gange)
- Present the negative examples that usually confuse students
- present examples in close succession or simultaneously
- assess the learning of the students: after learning the concept students should be able to work with new examples of that concept.
Teaching principles using the discovery method: implications for teaching
- describe the expected performance after learning the principle
- identify the concepts or principles that the students must recall in order to learn the new principle
- help students recall and revise the concepts involved in the principle
- help students combine the concepts in the correct order in deriving the principle
- give the students extensive practice with enough examples to reinforce their responses
- provide new examples and attempt to evaluate the learning of the principle
Advantages and disadvantages of the discovery approach
- it provides for understanding as opposed to rote learning
- students are actively engaged instead of being passive listeners
- concepts or principles taught are more easily remembered than facts
- greater interest and memory of things they found out by themselves
Disadvantages of the discovery approach
- time consuming
- requires a lot of materials
- knowledge is ever expanding so impossible for students to discover all concepts and principles themselves
back to top
DIRECT INSTRUCTION (EXPOSITORY)
Teacher transmits information directly to students (Gagne)
- advance organizers (Ausebel)
- state learning objectives and orient students to the lesson
- review pre-requisites: remind students about what they already know
- present new material: logically organized, emphasis, clarity, explanations, demonstration
- conduct learning probes: pose questions to students to assess their level of learning
- provide independent practice: be sure students can do it, short, clear instructions, avoid interruptions, monitor independent work, collect and mark it
- assess performance and provide feedback
- provide distributed practice and review (Dempster 1989).
back to top
PEER TUTORING
Tutoring of one student by another
Cross-age tutoring: an older student tutors a younger one
Cross-age peer tutors are more likely to know the material and are more readily accepted than same age tutors (Topping & Ely 1998)
Adequate training and monitoring of tutors is essential (Jenkins & Jenkins 1987)
Greater achievement gains for tutors than tutees (the best way to learn something is to teach someone else). back to top
PROGRAMMED INSTRUCTION
Individualized instruction methods in which students work on self-instructional materials at their own levels and rates
Students are expected to learn from the materials rather than principally from the teacher.
Programmed instruction provides better results when combined with cooperative learning (Slavin 1985)
Common in computer based instruction: individual instruction administered by a computer. back to top
STUDY TRIP/FIELD TRIP
Pre-trip activities
- Identify a topic where students could learn about the topic via a study trip
- Set the objectives
- Discuss with principal
- Discuss with students: checklist of goals, key things to learn, behavior
- Contact destination and make any necessary arrangements
- Discuss with the teachers
- Plan the method of assessment and communicate it with the students
Trip
- go to the location
- have students engaged in specific tasks related to the trip
Post trip activities
- discussion with the class
- report
- thank you letters
- teacher evaluates the effectiveness of the trip
back to top
LECTURE METHOD
- not interactive; questions may be invited at the end of the lecture
- presentation: organized
- Ausubel (1963, 1968) promoted the use of advance organizers to facilitate learning through this method
- In later secondary school it acts to prepare students for post-secondary education
- When to use the lecture method
- When introducing a new topic or unit
- When presenting important materials not easily obtainable
- When supplementing text book materials
- When developing interest and appreciation
- When summarizing important main points after a unit of study
- When attempting to cover a lot of material in a short time
- advantages of the lecture method
- when executed correctly it has a high inspirational and motivational value therefore it is good for generating interest
- supplemental and enriching to the text book
- teacher has complete control over the choice of knowledge students learn
- economy of time and effort
- can be used to teach large classes
- disadvantages of the lecture method
- violates the principle of learning through active involvement
- reduces students to passive recipients of ideas – discourages creativity
- not enough opportunity to practice oral communication skills
- student’s understanding is rarely assessed during the lecture
Lecture technique
- preparation
- careful planning
- clear objectives
- advance organizers (Ausubel ’63 and’68)
- outline of main points
- a few important points
- prepare illustrative materials
- short demonstration
- visual aids
- stories to help students to form mental images
- organization to present systematically
- introduction
- should be catchy and challenging
- keep them in suspense, create and expectant mood
- provide a logical outline on the board to deal with a complex topic
- presentation
- follow a logical order
- as lecture develops, provide main points on the board
- use of illustrative materials appropriately
- vary ways of presenting concepts
- humor
- life-like examples
- conclusion
- show inter-relatedness of ideas
Enhancing the effectiveness of the lecture
Personality counts: voice modulation, facial expressions, gestures
Talk to your students: make eye contact
Consciously observe student behavior
Adapt language to level of understanding back to top
DRILL AND PRACTICE
Used to reinforce, supplement, fix or add to what has already been learned
- Drill
- emphasis is on repetition for the purpose of memorizing important facts, and making automating the use of simple motor skills
- unthinking repetition of mental or motor practices
- used for:
- memorizing important facts
- memorizing verbatim definitions, laws, theories, principles or rules
- making important mental or motor skills automatic
- developing or fixing a habit
- Practice
- emphasis is on intelligent use or manipulation of facts for the acquisition of an ability to the point of accuracy or perfection
- meaningful, varied and purposeful repetition
- used for
- applying skills drilled in meaningful situations
- refining or polishing learned abilities
- technique
- identify the materials for drill or practice
- providing the model for the drill or practice (Modeling: Bandura’s learning theory)
- initial practice or drill
- varied practice
- individual exercise
- effective drill or practice
- students must have an adequate prior understanding
- more meaningful when practicing skills that are more closely knit together
- practice should be done in circumstances that resemble conditions under which the skill is normally carried out
- distributed over time with frequent breaks
- should be done under some time pressure
- correct mistakes as soon as they are spotted
- give more attention to weak areas exposed in drill and practice
- as soon as possible practice should be applied to what has been drilled
- individualize to meet particular needs of students
- as skills become more fixed, drill and practice sessions should decrease
- advantages of drill and practice
- drill and practice are effective for extending associations and skills
- they are efficient in refining or polishing skills
- they provide the basic foundation on which higher skills are built
- they are necessary for correcting and improving specific parts or aspects of a skill
- they reinforce retention, they are efficient techniques for developing ones ability to memorize
- disadvantages of drill and practice
- boring unless purpose is clear and accepted and motivation is high
- concentration hard to sustain
- may degenerate into rote learning if initial understanding is not developed
- time may be wasted if materials drilled are not really needed back to top
COOPERATIVE LEARNING (Johnson & Johnson 1994)
Instructional method in which students work in small mixed ability groups
Methods:
- Student Teams – Achievement Divisions (Slavin 1994):
- Most appropriate for teaching well defined objectives with single right answers
- A cooperative learning method for mixed-ability groupings involving team recognition and group responsibility for individual learning
- Teacher presents lesson
- Students work within team to make sure all team members master material (usually worksheets)
- Students take quizzes on individual level
- Quiz scores compared to their own past averages and points are awarded to the students which meet or exceed their own earlier performance
- Points summed to form team scores
- Teams meeting certain criteria earn certificates or other rewards
- steps:
- assign students to teams of four
- make worksheet and a short quiz for the lesson you plan to teach
- during team study team members are to master the material presented
- read off team assignments
- have students form groups and decide on a team name
- hand out worksheets or other study materials
- instruct students to be sure each member of the team works on the materials
- ensure they understand it is the group’s responsibility to make sure everyone understands
- not finished until they are sure all teammates will make 100% on the quiz
- provide answer sheets for the worksheet, since worksheets are for studying
- explain answers to one another
- ask teammate before asking teacher
- distribute quiz and give adequate time to complete it; working individually
- figure individual and team scores; team scores are based on improvements over their own past records
- recognition of team improvement back to top
DEMONSTRATION METHOD
An audio-visual explanation emphasizing the important points of a product, process or idea.
Learning by observing (Bandura)
Applied more in subjects involved in skill learning:
When teaching a skill
When materials and equipment are insufficient
When experimenting with dangerous solutions or chemicals
Preparing a demonstration:
Perform a task analysis (Gagne)
Prepare explanatory materials
Rehearse the demonstration
Prepare an outline
Prepare the environment
Decide on the type of demonstration: alone or with student assistance
Prepare the written material
Performing the demonstration
Establish the proper attitude: get their attention
Keep the demonstration simple
Do not deviate from main points
Pace demonstration for dramatic effect
Constantly check student’s understanding
Summarize and conclude the demonstration
Advantages:
Trains students to be good observers
Stimulates thinking and the formation of concepts and generalizations
Interesting
Economy of time
Effective introduction to learning a new skill
Appropriate when teaching students how to operate machinery or equipment
Disadvantages:
Provides less opportunity for discovery
Children are not active participants
In large classes problems of audibility and visibility arise
Difficult to evaluate thoroughly student understanding back to top |